The best research money can buy?

Below is an email I received from ColorofChange.org.   I share because of its relevance to the burgeoning problem of #racialprofiling and #policebrutality and violence against people of color.   Moreover,  this letter provides insight into financial incentives underlying our system of false  justice that targets those with pigment as well as motive to arrest and  frame innocent people of color, most of whom are youths, mentally ill or homeless.

ColorofChange.org petition to Temple University President Theobald:

Private-Prisons--temple-email 

Two Temple University professors released an inaccurate study praising private prisons without revealing a major conflict of interest — private prisons funded the study.1

 Unsurprisingly, the research argued in favor of for-profit imprisonment based on a number of dangerous myths — exactly the kind of inaccuracies that give the industry cover to keep exploiting Black communities for profit.

Private prisons are making a killing off the anti-black racism, abuse, and inhumanity of mass incarceration. In order to stop this shameful industry, we must expose any attempts to bolster its credibility among the public and state officials. Temple has agreed to look into a pending ethics complaint against the study, but it’s been a year and still no investigation.

Tell Temple President Neil Theobald to thoroughly investigate the pending ethics complaint, hold the authors of the study accountable, and create a new policy requiring researchers to reveal corporate funding at all stages of the research publication process. It just takes a moment.

Temple’s study was funded by the nation’s top three private prison companies: Corrections Corporation of America (CCA), GEO Group, and Management Training Corp (MTC). When initially released, Professors Simon Hakim and Erwin Blackstone included no information on its private prison funding.2 It was only after advocates filed an ethics complaint that the professors were forced to reveal their funding sources,3 but the damage had already been done. Public opinion had been influenced by a number of editorials by Professors Hakim and Blackstone published in newspapers nationwide, most of which did not mention their private prison funding.4

CCA, the country’s largest private prison company, was established after its founders decided managing prisons was just like “selling cars, or real estate, or hamburgers.”5

Since then, the industry has exploded, with the number of people in private prisons increasing by 1,664%.6 These corrupt companies have played a key role in lobbying for policies that increase imprisonment and worsen today’s mass incarceration crisis, fueled by the discriminatory War On Drugs.7 Due to continued prejudice in the justice system, Black people are the most likely to be incarcerated for profit in abusive private prisons.8 In order to increase profits, for-profit prisons cut costs on key services — meaning lower staffing levels, less training for guards, abysmal health care, and increased rates of violence.9

The Temple Study is dishonest and filled with inaccuracies, which the private prison industry leverages to deflect public outrage around its unethical business practices and human rights violations. 

Both CCA and GEO Group reference the Temple study in promotional materials as “independent” confirmation of the benefits of private prisons.10

A recent letter published by the ACLU reveals that Hakim and Blackstone’s methodology is deeply flawed.11 Their claims that private prison save states money fail to take into account increased state costs associated with higher recidivism rates found at private prisons, and the fact that companies get to “cherry pick” who they lock up — allowing them to choose healthier, less costly, people.

Temple University has an obligation to enforce its ethics policies and prevent corporations from funding “independent” research in secret. Please ask your friends and family to join in order to increase the power of our voices.

 

Thanks and Peace,

 

—Matt, Rashad, Arisha, Lyla, Jamar and the rest of the ColorOfChange.org team

July 7th, 2014

 

Help support our work.

 ColorOfChange.org is powered by YOU—your energy and dollars. We take no money from lobbyists or large corporations that don’t share our values, and our tiny staff ensures your contributions go a long way.

 

References

1. “University to review ethics complaint regarding two professors,” The Temple News, 06-13-2014 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3577?t=7&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

2. “PLN managing editor’s Temple University ethics complaint profiled,” Prison Legal News, 06-11-2014 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3578?t=9&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

3. “Ethics Complaint vs. Professors Hakim and Blackstone,” Human Rights Defense Center, 06-25-2013 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3632?t=11&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

4. See reference 2.

5. “The Dirty Thirty: Nothing to Celebrate About 30 Years of Corrections Corporation of America,” Grassroots Leadership, 01-30-2013 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3579?t=13&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

6.”The Number of People in Private Prisons Has Grown By 1,664% in the Last 19 Years,” Policy Mic, 01-25-2013 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3580?t=15&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

7. “Private Prison Companies Want You Locked Up,” Justice Policy, 06-22-2011 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3581?t=17&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

8. “Too Good to be True: Private Prisons in America,” Sentencing Project, 01-2012 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/2921?t=19&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

9. “The Color of Corporate Corrections, Part II: Contractual Exemptions and the Overrepresentation of People of Color in Private Prisons,” Journal of Radical Criminology, 09-2013 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3582?t=21&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

10. “The Case For Private Prisons,” Politico, 02-28-2014 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3625?t=23&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

11. “An Open Letter to the Corrections Corporation of America,” ACLU 07-1-2014 
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/3624?t=25&akid=3454.1756703.3UnWqW

Author: Angela Grant

I am a first generation Jamaican immigrant whose experiences and accomplishments were made possible by the courage, sacrifices and the heroic acts of many whose bodies have rotted away in unmarked graves. Those are my heroes. Their sacrifices and death paved the way for my children and I. Failure to Listen is a token of my eternal gratitude. Failure to Listen is a tribute those generations of unmarked graves occupied by people of all races whose ultimate sacrifice of life opened the door for me and others, THANK YOU. Failure to Listen https://failuretolisten.wordpress.com/ uses cultural lenses to appreciate and understand the relationships between current events and our values, beliefs and attitudes. Culture is everything without it we are nothing. Failure to Listen will take you on a journey to recognize the beauty of our differences as the seeds to creativity, innovation and resolving disparities. By sharing my personal and professional experiences, I hope to do justice to the perspectives of those who are rarely heard or listened to. This site is not to incite anger but rather to provoke thought. It is my hope that Failure to Listen will work to foster intergroup dialogues and motivate readers to step outside the box and get to know ALL PEOPLE. In the spirit of Martin Luther King, let's join hands and remember his famous speech about a dream... A small group of thoughtful people could change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. -Margaret Mead

2 thoughts on “The best research money can buy?”

  1. This is absolutely indefensible and morally bankrupt. It shows that opportunists can and will be found in every oppressed group. White failure to condemn it is liberalism of the worst kind – in fact, it is a particularly insidious and pernicious form of racism. If anyone needs more proof of the cynicism with which this nation is proceeding in the ruthless destruction of the mass of low income African-Americans, here it is. I can’t imagine that Temple University students will put up with this. If they do, we are all in deep trouble. But obviously they need our help. And the study is part of a huge national crises.
    I think its time for direct public obstructive ACTION.

    Liked by 1 person

Let your voice be heard, contribute to this discussion. What is your opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s