Central Park 5: What About The Innocent Victims Of A System Intentionally Flawed

Central Park 5

The Real Culprit in the Central Park 5 Convictions

To begin with, the notion that Fairstein and Lederer are uniquely evil suggests that the Central Park Five were uniquely victimized. The fact is, the Central Park wrongful convictions were system failures in which many people—cops, defenders, judges, forensic scientists—had a hand, either by making a mistake or failing to catch one.

As Diane Vaughan said of the Space Shuttle Challenger launch decision, conformity, not deviance, was at the root of the problem. We have to come to grips with the fact that the Central Park Five fiasco was not the work of a pair of sociopaths— not a once-every-30-years lightning strike. These wrongful convictions were very much “normal accidents”.

I haven’t seen the mini-series, ” When They See Us,”  but the article focuses on holding the system accountable instead of the people running the system.   Weren’t five innocent teenagers held responsible for a crime despite the lack of evidence?  What about the innocent victims of a system intentionally flawed to imprison black children and young adults?  That point is not of importance in this article.

It’s incredible to me the excuses rendered for egregious “normal accidents.” The article suggests the prosecutors should not be demonized like the innocent Central Park 5 or their families, despite being wrongfully convicted and imprisoned. The author is unsympathetic to their trauma and that of their families. They are barely mentioned, or the future stolen from them.

Again, weren’t they accountable and convicted as adults for a crime they never committed?  This article suggests the people involved in the cover-up of “normal accidents,” should not be responsible because the system is flawed. But isn’t the system flawed because of the culture and the people hired to run a system that maintains structural racism instead of justice?

Is it justice to force confessions from children then hold them to a higher standard than the adults who run the system or forced the confessions?


Author: Angela Grant

Angela Grant is a medical doctor. For 22 years, she practiced emergency medicine and internal medicine. She studied for one year at Harvard T. H Chan School Of Public Health. She writes about culture, race, and health.

5 thoughts on “Central Park 5: What About The Innocent Victims Of A System Intentionally Flawed

  1. In short: It’s the result of a “I’m just doing my job”, “I do as I’m ordered”, “I follow my leader”, and “I abide by the law” mentality, no matter what this job entails, the order is, the integrity of that leader, or the content of that law.

    I said it before, and say it again: It’s the pathology of normalcy.

    1. Hey Roald, how are you?

      So racism is part of that “normalcy.” A “normalcy” that harms people of color with no accountability because it’s “normal.” Yet that same normalcy has no qualms scapegoating innocent groups of people and their culture when one member of a group is accused of this normalcy. Is that the pathology of normalcy you speak of?

      1. Like I said, it’s pathological. But since (almost all) mainstream people are like that, you won’t find this sickness/disorder in the DSM or ICD, as it’s considered normal/healthy by them 👹

  2. When it, a comes to Black people beast is the “victim” any Black person will do. No matter if there is not evidence of it. Why is there have been a few Black men and women the were in prison for a long time now being released after no evidence of the crime.

    1. In the days of slavery and Jim Crow, Black men were often falsely accused by white women for crimes committed by whites. You know, “normal accidents.” The consequences of those normal accidents were lynching, pillaging, and raping communities of color. And they called themselves civilized.

Share your thoughts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.